diff --git a/lookyloo/lookyloo.py b/lookyloo/lookyloo.py
index b1fce40..88d5f35 100644
--- a/lookyloo/lookyloo.py
+++ b/lookyloo/lookyloo.py
@@ -317,8 +317,9 @@ class Lookyloo():
     def update_tree_cache_info(self, process_id: int, classname: str) -> None:
         self.redis.hset('tree_cache', f'{process_id}|{classname}', str(self._captures_index.lru_cache_status()))
 
-    def sorted_capture_cache(self, capture_uuids: Optional[Iterable[str]]=None) -> List[CaptureCache]:
-        '''Get all the captures in the cache, sorted by timestamp (new -> old).'''
+    def sorted_capture_cache(self, capture_uuids: Optional[Iterable[str]]=None, cached_captures_only: bool=True) -> List[CaptureCache]:
+        '''Get all the captures in the cache, sorted by timestamp (new -> old).
+        By default, this method will only return the captures that are currently cached.'''
         if capture_uuids is None:
             # Sort all recent captures
             capture_uuids = self.redis.hkeys('lookup_dirs')
@@ -326,6 +327,10 @@ class Lookyloo():
             # No captures at all on the instance
             return []
 
+        if cached_captures_only:
+            # Do not try to build pickles
+            capture_uuids = set(capture_uuids) & self._captures_index.cached_captures
+
         all_cache: List[CaptureCache] = [self._captures_index[uuid] for uuid in capture_uuids if self.capture_cache(uuid)]
         all_cache.sort(key=operator.attrgetter('timestamp'), reverse=True)
         return all_cache